Manufacturing / Production Technology, Hardware & Services


The importance of paying attention to component specifications

EMP 2018 Electronics Manufacturing & Production Handbook Manufacturing / Production Technology, Hardware & Services

The theory is simple: process electronics assemblies in spec every time and you will end up with a quality product.

In practice, this is more difficult for numerous reasons, including normal and abnormal process variation, human error and more.

But first, let’s be clear on what our process specifications really are.

Critical components such as LEDs, crystals, bottom-terminated components (BTC) including micro BGAs, and others have very specific process limits that can be challenging to achieve and devastating when missed. Electronics assemblers must fully understand the nomenclature and process window definitions before setting up their assembly machines. Maximum rising and falling slope limits when reflowing PCBs represent a common source of misunderstanding and failures.

Figure 1. Example of thermal process specifications for an LED component.
Figure 1. Example of thermal process specifications for an LED component.

Take an LED component as an example. Figure 1 shows a typical reflow process window or process limits for such a component (the terms slope and gradient are used interchangeably in this article).

Figure 1 appears easy and straightforward, right? Wrong. The devil is in the details, and the downside of getting it wrong is significant. First, a definition of a temperature slope: ‘the rate of temperature change with distance or time.’ In a thermal profile, this will be measured in °C or K (Kelvin) per second.

Figure 2. Average slope measurements.
Figure 2. Average slope measurements.

A common mistake is to calculate maximum rising and falling temperature gradients as a linear measurement from the start of the profile to peak temperature, and from the peak temperature to the end of the profile (Figure 2). These calculations are misleading and very different from the maximum slope because they average the various slope calculations along the profile. It reminds me of the old joke about the statistician, with his head in the oven and his feet in the refrigerator, who stated that the average temperature was comfortable.

To find the correct measurement of the slope, we need one more specification: the distance or time over which the slope will be measured. Reading the fine print in the LED component spec limits, we could find the following (as an example): maximum rising slope to be measured over 10 second intervals.

Figure 3. 10 second slope measurements in increments of 1 second.
Figure 3. 10 second slope measurements in increments of 1 second.

To calculate the maximum rising slope for the LED example above, we need to measure each 10 second slope along the profile from the beginning to peak temperature. To do that we select the profile temperature at 10 seconds, subtract the temperature at 0 seconds, and divide by 10 seconds. Next, we calculate the profile temperature at 11 seconds, subtract the temperature at 1 second and divide by 10 seconds and so forth. The calculations will continue in 1 second increments until the peak.

Finally, the highest number of all these calculations represents maximum rising slope. You will note that the 10 second maximum gradient measurement is significantly higher than the average gradient. Similar calculations will be made on the falling slope, but the component supplier will likely specify a different acceptable limit along with new calculation guidelines. The cooling section of the profile has a shorter duration and may be susceptible to more volatile temperature variations. The component specification may call for maximum falling slope measurements over a 5 second interval instead.

Figure 4. Maximum rising slope calculations.
Figure 4. Maximum rising slope calculations.

The use of average instead of maximum slope calculations will be misleading, and it risks component damage. What makes this particularly worrisome is that stressing LEDs or other optoelectronic and electronic components may introduce latent defects that enable the PCB to pass the factory’s quality inspection, but may fail prematurely when in use.

This may seem very complicated, but with modern profiling software it is straightforward. The calculations are made in a fraction of a second. You just need to study the specs and set the profiling software to perform slope calculations at the component and solder paste suppliers’ specifications for time interval. The 10 and 5 second specification used in this article are only examples. Make sure that the profiling software is capable of measuring the maximum slope over any duration limit. If there are several temperature-sensitive components with different specs, two options are available:

1. Use the most stringent specification for all components.

2. If the profiler supports different specs for each thermocouple (TC), you can attach the TCs to the critical components, making sure all of them are within their individual specs. This will be easier to achieve than the ‘lowest common denominator’ approach in the first method.

The larger challenge will be to set up the reflow oven to achieve a profile that accommodates the more demanding slope specs when using the correct calculations. Again, modern profiling software with prediction algorithms will do a good job of automatically selecting the appropriate oven recipe.

If, however, the slope specifications are defined for you by your client, and your reflow oven is not capable of achieving them even with powerful prediction software, then you may need to investigate further. Ensure that everybody involved is clear on the full definition of your thermal process window and the correct methods to calculate it. This is not a discussion on semantics but whether you are running your production in or out of spec, with all the risk that it entails.

For more information contact Techmet, +27 (0)11 824 1427, info@techmet.co.za, www.techmet.co.za



Credit(s)



Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Clean soldering tips in one second
Testerion Manufacturing / Production Technology, Hardware & Services
Weller has introduced the new WATC100 soldering tip cleaner which can clean soldering tips and desoldering tweezers quickly, efficiently and safely.

Read more...
Yamaha Robotics releases 3D hybrid AOI
Truth Electronic Manufacturing Manufacturing / Production Technology, Hardware & Services
With a 25-megapixel high-resolution camera, the AOI achieves approximately 1,6 times faster speed than previous models.

Read more...
Next gen high-speed modular mounter
Truth Electronic Manufacturing Manufacturing / Production Technology, Hardware & Services
This new addition is a next-generation, compact, high-speed modular mounter with space-saving qualities, and provides a combination of component compatibility and versatility.

Read more...
Modern vision systems in manufacturing
Manufacturing / Production Technology, Hardware & Services
Using an intelligent vision system provides a proactive approach, which helps prevent faulty products from reaching the market, thereby reducing customer complaints and minimising recall costs.

Read more...
Designing and manufacturing robust enclosures for extreme environments
Editor's Choice Manufacturing / Production Technology, Hardware & Services
The lifecycle of robust edge devices starts with design, and all aspects, including electronic components, packaging, shipping, installation, and servicing needs to be considered at the design stage to ensure that an edge device can operate in the environment it is intended for.

Read more...
Maximising soldering iron tip life
Vepac Electronics Manufacturing / Production Technology, Hardware & Services
During the soldering process, the soldering iron tip undergoes physical changes. These changes, over time, affect the ability of the soldering iron tip to make quality solder connections, and can decrease an operator’s performance.

Read more...
White residues on the assembly
Electronic Industry Supplies Manufacturing / Production Technology, Hardware & Services
When white residues suddenly appear on assemblies for unknown reasons, the customer is often confused – and the first idea is often the same: something must be wrong with the cleaner. But this is only the cause in extremely rare cases.

Read more...
Reducing solder paste spatter during reflow
Techmet Editor's Choice Manufacturing / Production Technology, Hardware & Services
Splash is a problem that solder paste will inevitably encounter during the welding process, and distinguishing between spatter and solder ball is the first step in solving the problem.

Read more...
Issues surrounding foam when cleaning
MyKay Tronics Manufacturing / Production Technology, Hardware & Services
Foam is a common issue in the electronic cleaning world, and this article lists the common issues and solutions to preventing foam build up.

Read more...
Clean soldering tips in one second
Allan McKinnon & Associates Manufacturing / Production Technology, Hardware & Services
Weller has introduced the new WATC100 soldering tip cleaner that can clean soldering tips and desoldering tweezers efficiently and safely in just one second.

Read more...