Editor's Choice

Smoke detection matters

30 September 2020 Editor's Choice Analogue, Mixed Signal, LSI

By far the biggest safety challenge in smoke detection is the saving of lives. Innovations in the smoke detection market have been driven by factors that include the following:

• Growth in industrial buildings: The International Energy Agency (IEA) predicts that the floor area of buildings globally is set to grow at approximately 3% per year. This is a result of increasing urbanisation and improved access to energy in developing countries.

• The increasing use of synthetic material within buildings.

This is why smoke detection regulations are critically important when the value proposition is as basic as human life itself. There are two predominant smoke detection technologies used in smoke detector systems:

• Ionisation systems.

• Photoelectric smoke detectors.

Here are some of the pending and current global standards and what they mean for smoke detection technology and markets.

A summary of global standards

There are basically five main global standards with different requirements to pass the respective certification. Smoke detector systems need to be fully tested as an end-product, but testing can also happen at the subsystem level. This does not substitute for full certification, but can give peace of mind before embarking on costly end system certification.

US and Canada

• UL 268: Smoke Detectors for Fire Alarm Systems.

7th edition: This was due to come into effect on 29 May 2020, although it may be delayed until 30 June 2021.

• UL 217: Smoke Alarms.

8th edition: This was due to come into effect on 29 May 2020, although it may be delayed until 30 June 2021.

These standards include updates to the polyurethane flaming and smouldering and cooking nuisance (hamburger) tests.


• EN 14604: Smoke Alarm Devices (2006).

• BS EN 54: Fire Detection and Fire Alarm Systems (2015).

Part 29: Multisensor fire detectors, these are point-type detectors using a combination of smoke and heat sensors.


• ISO 7240: Fire detection and alarm systems (2018).

Part 7: Point-type smoke detectors using scattered light, transmitted light, or ionisation.

The Chinese standard for point-type smoke detectors follows the 2003 edition of this standard.

Details on testing

There are two aspects to each standard, the tests and the requirements for test setup.

Fire room tests are expressed in terms of time to alarm after initiation of fire or in terms of obscuration levels (or in some cases both). Obscuration is a unit of measurement for the concentration of smoke. It measures the amount of light that reaches the detector in the presence of smoke compared to the amount of light that reaches the detector in clean air. The higher the value of obscuration, the higher the smoke concentration levels will be.

The most stringent testing standards are currently NA/Canada UL 217 and UL 268.

Some of the relevant tests are given below, but there are many more.

UL 217 (8th edition)/UL 268 (7th edition)

• Paper fire: Must give an alarm before t = 240 s.

• Wood fire: Must give an alarm before t = 240 s.

• Smouldering smoke: Must give an alarm before obscuration levels exceed 29,26%/m.

• Flaming polyurethane foam: Must give an alarm before obscuration levels exceed 15,47%/m and t = 360 s.

• Smouldering polyurethane: Must give an alarm before obscuration levels exceed 34,3%/m.

• Hamburger (nuisance alarm): Must not give an alarm/fault before obscuration levels exceed 0,987%/m or the MIC value is in the 59,3% to 49,2% range.

• Sensitivity test, dust test, high humidity test: Must not give an alarm/fault. The sensitivity test measures the obscuration level at which the unit alarms in a controlled smoke chamber.

• Flammable liquid fire (UL 268 Canada only). Must give an alarm before t = 240 s.

For EN 14604, BS EN 54 and ISO 7240, there can be different sensitivity levels on the same test or additional specifications pertaining to, for example, liquid (heptane) fire, glowing smouldering cotton, or low temperature, black smoke liquid fire.

For a complete set of tests, the relevant specification must be referenced in full.

Smoke detection technology: one size does not fit all

Each international region has a very detailed set of tests that have different methods and setups for testing.

Passing UL 217 and UL 268 standards − currently the most stringent two standards − can give a good indication of compliance, although this is not a substitute for regional testing.

Using a component or subsystem that is UL-listed gives peace of mind. UL component recognition means that UL has evaluated components or materials intended for use in a complete product or system. These components are intended only for end-use products that may be eligible for UL certification. The ADPD188BI plus smoke chamber is currently pending for UL listing.

The ADPD188BI smoke detection module integrates LEDs, a photodiode and an analog front end (AFE) in one small 3,8 mm × 5,0 mm × 0,9 mm package. The benefits include:

• A reduced component count.

• Meets new and existing regulations for life safety due to a high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and wide dynamic range for lower signal measurement.

• Reduced nuisance alarms to ensure verified alerts (and avoid alarm disable) by having two-colour detection and high dynamic range.

• Low power dissipation to allow more devices on wired or wireless loops.

• Small size to enable placement of detectors in hard to reach places.

• The elimination of LED supply chain management requirements.

• Running on a standard SMT assembly process.

The future

Regulatory changes have driven the trend toward smaller, more accurate smoke detection systems. In addition to the regulatory changes, customers are demanding better aesthetics and a wider range of trickier deployment scenarios. Meeting this demand will require smaller form factors at lower power.

About the author

Grainne Murphy is a marketing manager in ADI’s Intelligent Buildings Group. She is a University of Limerick, Ireland graduate (B.Eng) and holds an MBA from Oxford Brookes University. She can be reached at grainne.murphy@analog.com.

For more information contact Conrad Coetzee, Altron Arrow, +27 11 923 9600, ccoetzee@arrow.altech.co.za, www.altronarrow.com


Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Why you don’t take ‘touch’ for granted
30 September 2020 , Editor's Choice
The key criteria for choosing the right sensor control IC          Touch has become an incredibly intuitive way for people to interact with high-tech devices. In just a few short years after the first ...

Double the power output from new Tadiran battery
30 September 2020, Altron Arrow , Power Electronics / Power Management
Tadiran has developed the latest in its PulsesPlus HLC battery range, doubling the power output of its previous offering. Recently the company launched the C-type HLC which represented a huge improvement ...

High-voltage analog multiplexers
30 September 2020, Altron Arrow , Analogue, Mixed Signal, LSI
Diodes Incorporated announces the PS508 and PS509 analog multiplexers that are capable of switching signal voltages of up to 36 V in an industrial environment. The high voltage capability of the devices ...

Low inductance SiC power module gate driver kit
31 August 2020, Altron Arrow , Analogue, Mixed Signal, LSI
The transformation to electrify transportation – from trains, trams and trolleys to buses, automobiles and EV chargers – continues at a rapid pace, as countries shift toward improved modes of transit ...

Women taking the lead in engineering
31 August 2020 , Editor's Choice, News
Alaris Antennas is an engineering company specialising in the design and production of (often) customised antennas for electronic warfare. This is not an industry that typically attracts women to steer ...

DACs with 1 or 2 channels
31 August 2020, Altron Arrow , Analogue, Mixed Signal, LSI
The MCP47CXBXX/MCP48CXBXX are single- and dual-channel 8-bit, 10-bit and 12-bit buffered voltage output digital-to-analog converters (DAC), with volatile or MTP memory and an I2C/SPI interface. The MTP ...

Generating very low voltages with standard regulators
30 September 2020, Altron Arrow , Power Electronics / Power Management
Question:    What is a good solution for generating a tiny DC supply voltage of a few hundred millivolts?       Answer: All that is needed is a clean additional positive voltage to hook up to the feedback ...

Personality profile: Mervyn Stocks
30 September 2020, Denver Technical Products , Editor's Choice
Mervyn Stocks, the founder and MD of Denver Technical Products, started his career as a learner technician, worked at some well-known companies in the industry before setting out on his own.

Forbatt SA invests in South Africa
30 September 2020, Forbatt SA , Editor's Choice, News
Forbatt SA is set to offer an improved service to the industry by making sure it has the products and solutions the industry needs, as well as a new showroom.

How 5G will influence autonomous driving systems
30 September 2020, Concilium Technologies , Editor's Choice, Telecoms, Datacoms, Wireless, IoT
Wireless communication technologies like 5G offer three major benefits: safer roads, more efficient traffic routing and more in-vehicle convenience.