The true cost of manufacturing in South Africa

7 August 2013 News

I have often been asked what gets me up in the mornings and what makes me want to run for the hills with respect to owning and running my own business. There are many more happy and positive things that get me up everyday than issues that get me down but today I wanted to share some of the challenges that we face on a daily basis.

Mike Goodyer.
Mike Goodyer.

I once had a dear sweet old grandmother who by God’s will and grace lived to be almost 95. In her later years she resided in a Catholic-run old age home where she was well cared for until her last days. Shortly before she died, the senior sister had one day gone to the chapel and heard a faint crying.

She found my gran seated at the back of the chapel and when asked what was wrong, my dear old gran replied in tears, “I am afraid that God has forgotten me here.” I relate to this story as I very often stand facing my daily challenges and I ask the same question: has the SA government forgotten about us? Almost everything that is out of my control seems to be stacked against us.

I have always felt that any manufacturing done in any country is of utmost importance to that country’s economy and for the provision of jobs; and I include the mining sector in that rather broad statement of course. I believe that any business manufacturing products that could be imported should be protected and nurtured wherever naturally possible.

Currently my feeling is we are being helped by the right hand but slapped on the head by the left hand. The imposing of a 20%+ tariff on imported fully assembled PCBs for TVs and STBs has had a dramatic effect on my business and allowed us to both employ more staff and reinvest in modern state-of-the-art assembly machines.

However, tariff protection while it lasts is great for local manufacturers but is a false and non-sustainable system that ends up costing the man in the street money. How great would it be to compete head to head with the rest of the world and come out on top so that we do not need tariff protection, we simply compete based on improved productivity and lower actual costs?

Alas, the left hand dictates how we must run our business and constantly forces us to incur costs making it nearly impossible to compete head-on.

The challenges we face include: erratic and at times unavailable power (as we have upgraded our plant we need more power and simply cannot get it); biased labour laws and dealing with the likes of Numsa (National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa) has made us very reluctant to keep employing people freely and as required; illogical tariff codes on certain raw materials remain a challenge; and of course the final stumbling block for my business currently is the challenges that the new BEE codes present.

I do not want to harp on about BEE as it is already a contentious and highly politicised issue, but I have to say that it is being extremely thoroughly implemented and is making it nearly impossible to run the business without being compliant. This is despite the fact that Microtronix employs close to 300 people, we are manufacturing in a high-tech sector competing well against Chinese costs, and we have a strong management team made up of black, white and Indian people chosen for their skills and not skin colour.

We have implemented a strong training programme where 20 young matric leavers have been trained up and are now valuable members of our staff. We have funded a small startup company with a black shareholder for our ‘allocated points’ and literally ticked every possible box, yet we still cannot reach a high enough score to target any government tender successfully.

Is our government honestly going to exclude my 300 employees the opportunity for a stable and secure future and a job because the company’s owner is white? It is a pretty hard concept to swallow considering my first task having left school was to vote in the first free and fair elections in SA with the same equal opportunities afforded every South African after the fall of apartheid.

I had to smile at the irony the other day when applying for funding from our bankers for additional equipment that will provide about 30 additional jobs: I was asked for my BEE certificate as it would have a bearing on us getting the loan...

I sometimes feel that the very system we are supporting is trying its best to make it as difficult to succeed as possible. I do not agree with the weighting of the BEE system, as there are zero credits for employing people. Is unemployment that low on the scale?

I look at what many South Africans are doing and feel it may be easier to team up with a few of my senior black and Indian management team, obtain a good BEE level and simply start importing from China like everyone else. Local content is beginning to play a role but without a Level 3 score you cannot even get in the door.

Over and above all these challenges, my greatest by far was the Numsa strike and the subsequent engagement with this organisation. The true cost of industrial action is not the loss of income, it is not the loss of productivity, it is not the loss of wages, it is not even the damage done to property as all of this can be rectified, rebuilt, fixed and money can be made again.

No, the true cost is the damage done to the relationship between the staff and management. It is the emotional damage done to the leader of the pack; a strike is like a vote of no confidence from your staff. They place their trust in an organisation that gives empty promises and unsustainable expectations and abandon the trust of the person who has employed them for the past 20 years.

How can one bravely fight on, remain motivated and tackle the challenges everyday when the people you lead and rely on tell you they are not happy and engage in industrial action? This has been my most challenging task to overcome: after the emotional damage done by the Numsa strike two years ago, to remain positive and upbeat about our future as a company and a country.

These challenges are stated from a personal level and generally the happy working disposition of our staff has returned. Currently Microtronix is in great shape with a full order book, greatly improved quantity levels across the board and another high-volume production line on the way. Those are the positive things that get me up each day and drive me to succeed against all odds, but more on that next time I am afforded the privilege of your time to share my humble views.

For more information contact Mike Goodyer, Microtronix, +27 (0)11 792 5322,,


Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Locked down but not knocked out
25 March 2020, ExecuKit , News
As a business, we are facing extremely hard times with the current worldwide pandemic and isolation. We are all maintaining social distancing and must learn how to do business with an enforced lockdown ...

From the editor’s desk: A new era – after mourning comes rebuilding
29 April 2020, Technews Publishing , News
When I sit down to write these columns once a month, even if the topic I decide to write about is not all sunshine and roses, I always try and look for a silver lining. I’m simply not able to do that ...

Personality profile: Chris Viveiros
29 April 2020, Otto Wireless , News
The operations director of Otto Wireless Solutions shares his background, experience, advice and thoughts on the future.

Locked down but not knocked out
29 April 2020, ExecuKit , News
We as a company salute the component suppliers who have supported us and are there to assist during this time even if the requests we pose are not always realistic.

Electronics industry tackling the coronavirus
29 April 2020 , News
2020 has been a crazy year already. From Australian bushfires to climate emergencies to US trade tariffs, the start of the decade hasn’t been very positive. Not only this, within the last few months there ...

SqwidNet becomes first Sigfox-accredited lab in southern hemisphere
29 April 2020, iSERT , News
iSERT (Safety, EMC, RF, Testing), a leader in the provision of turnkey testing solutions for EMC, RF and safety testing, has collaborated with SqwidNet, the only licenced Sigfox operator in South Africa, ...

Clearing the Static: ESD cleaning and hygiene products
29 April 2020, Altico Static Control Solutions , News
In light of the current COVID-19 pandemic, Actum Group would like to remind electronics manufacturers of our range of antistatic cleaning agents, cleanroom materials and PPE.       Cleanroom garments and ...

Jemstech continuing its growth path
29 April 2020, Jemstech , News
Since its inception in 2005 and especially during the past five years, Jemstech has grown from a medium-sized electronic manufacturing services (EMS) provider into one of the major players for electronics ...

Company profile: Phoenix Contact
29 April 2020, Phoenix Contact , News
Phoenix Contact was founded in 1923 in Essen, Germany, by Hugo Knümann. It entered the South African market in 1969 through a local distributor, and was later established as a wholly owned subsidiary ...

In memoriam: Vivienne Caroline Dorrington - 19 June 1958 – 21 April 2020
29 April 2020, Technews Publishing , News
It is with great sadness that we announce the death of our CEO, Vivienne Dorrington, after a long and brave battle with cancer. Like her father, Ray Beaumont, who founded Technews Publishing in 1985, ...