News


RoHS: the good, the bad and the ugly

6 April 2005 News

What do franchised distribution, the independent channel and a chip counterfeiter have in common? The rapidly approaching RoHS Directive looks set to transform their respective businesses in some way.

The franchised distributor should, in theory anyway, have the easiest role in tackling the challenges presented by the Directive. After all, they have direct relationships with the original IC manufacturers, so they have all of the answers - do they not?

Let us not forget, this is a formidable task - there are an estimated 100 000 products affected by RoHS across Europe. Add to that some 13 000 EOL (end of life) notifications per month and the scale of the problem becomes apparent. But precisely where is the bottleneck? Why, given that July 2006 is almost upon us, is there so much uncertainty surrounding compliance.

Recent industry reports cite a growing sense of frustration within the distribution community regarding the lack of RoHS data emerging from the component manufacturers. This frustration has allegedly escalated to a point where some distributors are openly considering removing certain franchises from their line cards. Only time will tell if these hollow threats mark the beginning of a change in the supply chain landscape.

One thing is certain - those distributors that have embraced the green issue will undoubtedly win market share.

Independent distribution, though not at the forefront of lead-free legislation, could still experience a period of uncertainty in the wake of RoHS. An independent's traditional activity has focused on component shortages. With a significant number of components yet to be manufactured in RoHS compliant variants, satisfying any RoHS compliant shortages from within the channel may prove difficult if not impossible. Whilst the legislation is unlikely to generate a component famine, many component manufacturers are still reporting only sporadic demand for lead (Pb)-free devices, making accurate forecasting as we go forward virtually impossible.

The sector that has the most potential to benefit from the RoHS Directive could actually be the criminal fraternity. Counterfeit components, a growing menace in modern electronics, are not that difficult to manufacture. In fact, they are not manufactured at all in the usual sense. You simply take a component and remove its markings. Now remark the device with another part number from a product that shares the same outline package and dimensions. The part number you select should obviously be more expensive and ideally in short supply. Of course it will not work, but that is not important as repeat orders are understandably rare within the counterfeit community.

Thankfully, forged components have been relatively easy to identify due to the primitive methods employed in remarking. Whilst we are not suggesting they are printed with potatoes, they do not usually employ sophisticated laser marking. Even if they make it past a visual inspection, they will almost certainly fail an electrical test by doing the unexpected, or perhaps nothing at all.

Now picture a more challenging scenario: a component manufacturer has been selling a part for many years. It is a popular device, used in various applications, but it contains lead (Pb) - a substance controlled by the imminent RoHS Directive. After much research and reliability testing, the manufacturer releases a Pb-free variant and adds a 'G' suffix to the original part number.

However, despite this new introduction, there are still considerable volumes of the original product within the supply chain. It would be relatively easy for the forger to 'tweak' the original part number to create an RoHS compliant counterfeit. The goods are already in the original packaging, as they are - to all intents and purposes, original.

This 'factory new' product would be considerably more difficult to identify. Moreover, electrical testing will not reveal the fake, as it is not really a counterfeit in the traditional sense. It will still perform as its datasheet suggests it should - it simply contains lead (Pb) on its terminations. Disturbingly, this illegal use of lead would probably only be identified by laboratory analysis, or a future audit by the enforcement authorities.

This extract comes from a series of RoHS component guides produced by Dionics, freely available at www.pb-free.info/guidance_documents.htm. For any other information contact Dionics, [email protected]





Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Webinar – How to develop intelligence edge IoT devices
News
Join Quectel’s expert-led webinar, with a speaker from Qualcomm Technologies, to learn more about how to plan, test and deploy successful IoT devices drawing on the unique advantages of intelligence at the edge.

Read more...
SAIMC training at AATF 2025
News
The SAIMC will deliver a powerful series of training sessions and technical workshops during AATF 2025, providing engineers, technologists, and technicians with the tools they need to professionally register, stay compliant, and lead industrial innovation.

Read more...
Webinar – Discover the ST BrightSense ecosystem
News
This webinar is for camera systems developers who need effective, ready-to-use solutions to keep pace with edge AI vision technologies and the rise of new applications spanning factory automation, robotics and drones, healthcare, traffic and security, sports and entertainment, and personal electronics.

Read more...
Altron celebrates 60th birthday with a call to rebuild Johannesburg
Altron Arrow News
Altron is celebrating its 60th birthday by honouring Johannesburg’s heritage and encouraging business, government and civil society to come together and respond to our President’s call to rebuild Johannesburg.

Read more...
Electronic News Digest
News
A brief synopsis of current global news relating to the electronic engineering fields with regards to company finances, general company news, and engineering technologies.

Read more...
Jemstech to produce PCB assemblies for Kamstrup
Jemstech News
Jemstech is pleased to announce that they have successfully concluded a supplier agreement with Kamstrup A/S in Denmark, a leading supplier of intelligent metering solutions in the global market.

Read more...
New appointments at Hiconnex
Hiconnex News
Hiconnex, a leading provider of electronic components and solutions, has announced key appointments to support its continued growth and commitments to its clients.

Read more...
FoundriesFactory service more affordable for smaller OEMs
News
Foundries.io has announced a new, tiered pricing scheme which reduces the cost of its highly regarded FoundriesFactory service for OEMs in the development phase of a new edge AI or Linux OS-based product.

Read more...
DMASS 2024 results
News
The semiconductor business faced a severe downturn, with a 31,9% decrease compared to 2023 and a 30,3% drop in Q4 2024 compared to the same period last year.

Read more...
Using satellite comms to end copper theft
News
According to Transnet COO Solly Letsoalo, the scourge of copper theft could be a thing of the past by eliminating the use of copper cabling and switching to a satellite communication system.

Read more...