mobile | classic
Dataweek Electronics & Communications Technology Magazine





Follow us on:
Follow us on Facebook Share via Twitter Share via LinkedIn


Search...

Electronics Buyers' Guide

Electronics Manufacturing & Production Handbook 2019


 

Selecting the right power LED driver topology
12 November 2008, Opto-Electronics

There is no such thing as a universal power LED driver circuit.

In reality, different power LED applications can have very different technical requirements. And there is a wide choice of components available, at a wide range of prices, to meet these requirements.

In other words, the decision over the choice of a driver circuit for a lighting application is complex, and has reference to many variables. To help the design engineer avoid the waste of time and effort involved in evaluating different power topologies through trial and error, this article elaborates a systematic method for choosing the right topology in the light of a clear and simple set of application parameters.

The key considerations that have to be borne in mind in order to reach the right decision are:

* What is the power source (AC mains, low-voltage DC, battery or other)?

* What is the relationship between the input and output voltages?

* What is the range of voltages required in the system?

* What is the power requirement?

* Is isolation required?

* Is dimming required?

* Does the supply have to power multiple channels (for instance in RGB colour-mixing applications)?

* What are the EMC constraints?

* What is the bill of materials budget?

A decision tree leading from the particular conditions of a circuit to a topology and component type that best meets the demands of the application provides a valuable first level of discrimination between the various methods for powering LEDs – see Figure 1. The design engineer will still have choices, between topologies (in some cases) and between components (in all cases). Then, secondary features, such as an IC’s ability to provide pulse width modulation (PWM) control, can make one device preferable to another.

Figure 1. High-level decision tree for LED power circuit topologies.
Figure 1. High-level decision tree for LED power circuit topologies.

But it is essential to productive design that the first high-level choice – that of topology – is right.

The unusual challenges in powering lighting systems

The design engineer faced with the specification for a power LED system could be forgiven for thinking they have been given an impossible mission. On the one hand, the power circuit must deliver a steady, high power output at very high efficiency (system-level efficiency is one of the main selling points of the latest generation of power LEDs.)

On the other hand, a tight bill of materials (BOM) budget nearly always applies. The LED itself is generally replacing a much cheaper conventional light source; there is therefore very strong pressure on the engineer to ensure that the power circuit does not add to the cost disadvantage of the power LED system.

It gets worse: power semiconductor manufacturers have thrived for many years in a market that demanded many flavours of constant-voltage regulator. As a result, there are thousands of such devices readily available at very competitive prices.

Unfortunately, these cheap and useful products are not geared to the needs of the lighting circuit designer, who must deliver a constant-current output, not a constant voltage. Power IC manufacturers are moving quickly to meet the very fast-growing demand for LED drivers, but many devices target particular applications or requirements. This can endow them with features or specifications that might not be optimised for general use.

LED power circuits: factors to consider

As Figure 1 shows, the first factor to consider when deciding on a driver topology is the kind of power source that is to be used. Next is the ratio between input and output voltages. It is in general simple to match the current and voltage ratings of a power IC to the specification of the circuit. These ratings come into sharper focus at relatively high values, however, where a controller with external switches can become necessary.

Options within and beyond the decision tree

As can be seen, the decision tree in Figure 1 provides a useful guide to ensure the designer avoids building prototypes using a topology that is clearly unsuited to the task. But how is the designer to make the choice between different topologies when the decision tree points to more than one candidate?

This is where the constraints of power LED system design come into play – the balancing of features (such as flexible PWM control) and efficiency against BOM cost.

This can best be illustrated by reference to a specific application example. Consider an application in which the designer has the flexibility to choose the input voltage. In this instance the resistor can be ignored; theoretically it could be used here, but it is a crude approach to the problem and provides no regulation. This leaves the choice of three more or less simple topologies.

A linear driver such as the NUD4001 from ON Semiconductor gives excellent current regulation and creates no electromagnetic emissions. Linear drivers are also simple to use and cost little. A linear driver can operate very efficiently provided the voltage overhead can be kept low and the LEDs’ forward voltage stays within tight tolerances.

This second requirement, however, is not straightforward – power LEDs with a binned forward voltage are hard to get and the cost is higher. If the end application has a medium-to-high production volume, it is invariably not possible to source LEDs from a single bin. In addition, a linear driver can dissipate only a moderate amount of power; in practice, the NUD4001 can drive at most two power LEDs.

So what if the application uses more than two LEDs, and/or there is a large difference between the input and output voltages? In this case, a switching topology is more appropriate, as it is a more efficient way of handling varying circumstances.

Two topologies offer a simple implementation: the buck topology and the boost topology. Both offer high efficiency over a wide range of electrical parameters. Both also create electromagnetic emissions, which need to be managed in order to comply with EMC regulations.

The two topologies achieve their effect in different ways, and these differences affect the efficiency with which they operate. In the buck topology shown in Figure 2, the LED is in series with the inductor. This means that only a fraction of the energy has to pass through the inductor, the component which contributes a significant part of the losses. In this topology, the average current through the inductor is no more than the current through the LED.

Figure 2. Buck topology exemplified by LM3404 device from National Semiconductor
Figure 2. Buck topology exemplified by LM3404 device from National Semiconductor

In the boost configuration, all the energy passes through the inductor, as it is charged to ground and then discharged through the LED, averaged by a capacitor. In addition, the current through the inductor is higher than the current through the LED; losses increase with the square of the current. In practice, in a circuit with comparable power output, a typical boost regulator such as Zetex Semiconductors’ ZXLD1321 in Figure 3 will deliver around 85% efficiency versus around 95% for a typical buck converter such as the LM3404 from National Semiconductor in Figure 2.

Figure 3. Boost topology exemplified by ZXLD1321 device from Zetex
Figure 3. Boost topology exemplified by ZXLD1321 device from Zetex

Conclusion

There is not, then, one ‘best’ driver circuit for power LEDs. Lighting designers are now learning to experiment with the new possibilities afforded by solid-state lighting, but already it is perfectly clear that the highly standardised form factors and uniform light outputs of traditional incandescent lamps are going to be replaced by a rich variety of new luminaire types using the small size and easy controllability of LEDs to do many new things with light.

Power circuits will reflect this diversity, and for the engineer tasked with designing them, a familiarity with the various potential power topologies will be essential.

For more information contact Marian Ledgerwood, Future Electronics, +27 (0)21 421 8292, marian.ledgerwood@futureelectronics.com, www.futureelectronics.com


Credit(s)
Supplied By: Future Electronics
Tel: +27 21 421 8292
Fax: 086 623 4522
Email: craig.hemmes@futureelectronics.com
www: www.futureelectronics.com
  Share on Facebook Share via Twitter Share via LinkedIn    

Further reading:

  • High-temperature TVS MLVs
    25 September 2019, Future Electronics, Circuit & System Protection
    The new TransGuard VT Series multilayer varistors (MLV) made by AVX are rated for transient voltage suppression (TVS) applications operating at very high temperatures. They provide reliable, bidirectional ...
  • LED flicker, and how to prevent it
    28 August 2019, Avnet South Africa, Opto-Electronics
    With the growing popularity of LED lighting, especially now that very cheap LED luminaires are coming to the market, flicker is becoming more of a problem. Flicker, a repetitive switching on and off ...
  • Digital fibre-optic sensor
    28 August 2019, Vepac Electronics, Opto-Electronics
    The DFS digital fibre-optic sensor series from Tri-Tronics is designed to provide reliable detection using plastic fibre-optic light guides. The slim-line housing with protective lid will fit in a variety ...
  • All-in-one light pipe system
    28 August 2019, Vepac Electronics, Opto-Electronics
    Bivar’s Zero Light Bleed adaptor technology, with built-in surface-mount LED, channels light directly to the lens, eliminating disruptive light bleed. The all-in-one adaptor system is built with optimum ...
  • RF coaxial IDC connectors
    28 August 2019, Future Electronics, Interconnection
    AVX has released new wire-to-board RF coaxial IDC connectors for industrial and automotive applications. The initial release of the new 00-6791 Series is comprised of two small, single-piece solutions ...
  • High-intensity colour LEDs
    31 July 2019, Würth Elektronik eiSos, Opto-Electronics
    Würth Elektronik has expanded its LED portfolio with a particularly compact model family. The WL-SMCC series of SMT chip LEDs, available in 0402 and 0603 packages, is characterised by a full-surface lens ...
  • RGB LEDs for decorative lighting
    26 June 2019, Würth Elektronik eiSos, Opto-Electronics
    Würth Elektronik’s new WL-SFTW and WL-SFTD series of RGB LEDs are targeted at accent and decorative lighting, optical displays as well as industrial applications. Thanks to their PLCC contacting design, ...
  • 4,3” TFT LCD module
    26 June 2019, iCorp Technologies, Opto-Electronics
    The RFE430W-AYW-DNN from Raystar is a 4,3” TFT display with a resolution of 480 x 270 pixels. It has a built-in SC7283 driver IC and supports an RGB 24-bit interface, with brightness of 500 nits, an aspect ...
  • High-intensity colour LEDs
    26 June 2019, Würth Elektronik eiSos, Opto-Electronics
    Würth Elektronik has expanded its LED portfolio with a particularly compact model family. The WL-SMCC series of SMT chip LEDs, available in 0402 and 0603 packages, is characterised by a full-surface lens ...
  • Time-to-digital converter
    29 May 2019, Future Electronics, Analogue, Mixed Signal, LSI
    ams has introduced the AS6500, a new high-resolution time-to-digital converter (TDC) featuring CMOS inputs and compact packaging for use in space- and cost-constrained applications. It can measure time ...
  • LEDs recognised for achieving natural light spectrum
    29 May 2019, NuVision Electronics, Opto-Electronics
    Seoul Semiconductor’s SunLike range of natural spectrum LEDs, first announced in 2017, have gone on to be recognised as an innovative technology for human-centric lighting at global lighting awards held ...
  • Infrared detectors
    29 May 2019, Würth Elektronik eiSos, Opto-Electronics
    Würth Elektronik eiSos is expanding its optoelectronics portfolio. Following infrared LEDs, the company now also offers a wide range of matching detectors. Developers of various infrared applications ...

 
 
         
Contact:
Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd
1st Floor, Stabilitas House
265 Kent Ave, Randburg, 2194
South Africa
Publications by Technews
Dataweek Electronics & Communications Technology
Electronics Buyers’ Guide (EBG)

Hi-Tech Security Solutions
Hi-Tech Security Business Directory

Motion Control in Southern Africa
Motion Control Buyers’ Guide (MCBG)

South African Instrumentation & Control
South African Instrumentation & Control Buyers’ Guide (IBG)
Other
Terms & conditions of use, including privacy policy
PAIA Manual





 

         
    Classic | Mobile

Copyright © Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd. All rights reserved.