Circuit & System Protection


Comparison of technologies used in surge protection devices

24 April 2002 Circuit & System Protection

The solutions employed to protect low voltage networks against transient overvoltages induced by lightning strikes - surge protection devices (SPDs) - are now widely spread. However, the choice between the different technologies available on the market is not that easy. Various solutions are available, especially in the 'high energy' SPD segment, for products used in sites with a lightning protection system - according to the Class I test of the international standard IEC61643-11) - or used in sites under extreme stress.

SPD technologies

The main technologies used in low voltage SPDs are described below:

* Air spark gap. Device generally made of two electrodes facing each other (V shape). The spark appears between the electrodes (+ the follow-up current) when an overvoltage reaches a certain value. On power networks, in order to stop the follow-up current, the principle of 'arc quenching' is used, the final consequence being the expulsion of the hot gas: this behaviour requires a special installation.

* Encapsulated spark gap: Air spark gap where the extinction of the follow-up current is achieved without expulsion of gas: this usually reduces the capacity to switch off the follow-up current.

* Gas discharge tube: Device made of an hermetic envelope, filled up with rare gas under a controlled pressure. This component is usually used and is well adapted to the protection of telecom networks. Its main feature is its very low follow-up current extinction capability and its much better stability than the air spark gap.

* Varistor: Nonlinear component (the resistance varies according to the voltage) made of zinc oxide (ZnO) that allows a limitation of the voltage. The clamping nature of operation enables avoidance of follow-up current which turns the varistor into a component very well adapted to the protection of the power networks.

* Varistor with thermal disconnection: Varistor equipped with an auxiliary device to disconnect the component in case of overheating: this behaviour is indispensable to guarantee a controlled end of the life of the varistors connected to the power network and to comply with the standard. In order to increase the discharge current, an efficient solution is to put in parallel a selection of varistors (Citel DS150E).

* GDT+varistor: Association of components in series to take advantage of both technologies: no leakage current and very low Up (maximum residual voltage) - gas discharge tube section and no follow-up current (varistor). To reach high amplitude of impulse current, technologies of association of specific gas discharge tubes (Citel DS150VG) will be needed.

Table 1 presents and compares the main features of the different technologies used in the high energy SPD. (Italics indicates preferential value).
Table 1 presents and compares the main features of the different technologies used in the high energy SPD. (Italics indicates preferential value).

Final analysis

It clearly appears that the technologies based on varistors (DS150E) and varistors+gas discharge tubes (DS150VGT) are the best compromise, with the exception of what concerns the discharge capacities in wave 10/350 µs. However, the estimation of real risk, as well as feedback from the field, shows that values of 15 kA in wave 10/350 are high enough.

For further information contact Citel representative in South Africa, Epsilon, (011) 622 5055.





Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Clearing the Static: Staying grounded: Ensuring effective ESD control
Actum Electronics Circuit & System Protection
To maintain reliable electrostatic discharge control, regular testing and accurate measurement are essential, with grounding products and ESD testing equipment being vital.

Read more...
Clearing the Static: ESD component safety in storage and transportation
Actum Electronics Circuit & System Protection
Conductive containers create a Faraday cage effect, safely channelling electrostatic charges away from the components inside.

Read more...
Clearing the Static: Conductive foot, heel and shoe grounders
Actum Electronics Circuit & System Protection
Conductive foot, heel and shoe grounders are used in electrostatic discharge protected areas to provide a path to ground for static electricity.

Read more...
LED driver for industrial power supply indication
Altron Arrow Editor's Choice Circuit & System Protection
A simple and small solution for driving an LED to provide visual feedback in the presence/absence of a system’s power using a chip not originally designed for this purpose.

Read more...
Clearing the Static: Cleaning in an ESD-protected area
Actum Electronics Circuit & System Protection
Cleaning in a protected electrostatic discharge area is a critical task to maintain the integrity of sensitive electronic components and prevent damage caused by static electricity.

Read more...
Clearing the Static: Key principles of ESD control in electronics manufacturing
Actum Electronics Circuit & System Protection
Effectively managing electrostatic discharge is essential in electronics manufacturing to ensure not only product reliability, but also worker safety.

Read more...
Clearing the Static: Three steps for a dry ESD packaging system
Actum Electronics Circuit & System Protection
For optimal storage, it’s essential to complete the dry-packaging system by adding Desiccant Packs and Humidity Indicator Cards.

Read more...
Ensuring safety with earth leakage protection
NewElec Pretoria Circuit & System Protection
Earth leakage protection helps mitigate the risks of electric shocks, fires, and equipment damage by swiftly identifying faults and disconnecting the power supply, thus safeguarding both human lives and machinery.

Read more...
Suppressing EMI with filters
Vepac Electronics Circuit & System Protection
EMI/RFI filters play an important role in reducing the high-frequency noise that is generated by various electrical and electronic devices.

Read more...
Patch attenuates like a shielding cabinet
Würth Elektronik eiSos Circuit & System Protection
Würth Elektronik has launched its hybrid WE-EMIP EMI absorber sheet, a convenient solution for reducing electromagnetic interference by up to 40 dB.

Read more...