Editor's Choice

Don’t be fooled by substandard, cheap antennas

31 January 2018 Editor's Choice News Telecoms, Datacoms, Wireless, IoT

Poynting, a company specialising is antenna design and manufacturing in South Africa, has issued a public service announcement warning that it is seeing a large number of sub-standard antennas being sold to the public. According to the company, people are being enticed by the appealingly similar or better specifications when compared to the reputable brands, but at much lower prices.

Dr. Fourie, who is a product specialist and chairman at Poynting Group, reports that they have tested some of these substandard antennas and can confirm that their performance is nowhere close to what their specifications imply: “These specifications are not only misleading, but the antennas are terrible,” he stresses. He goes on to say that tests performed by Poynting showed that antenna specifications of these antennas are highly overstated and often have horrendous radiation patterns with severe voltage standing wave ratio (VSWR) issues and antenna gain figures being exaggerated.

The antenna is an intricate part of the whole solution, and this seemingly simple device can easily negate the performance of the equipment it is connected to. “We often see expensive router and gateway equipment being installed, only to find out that the whole system’s performance was compromised by using poor performing antennas to save a few Euros,” continues Fourie, “You purchase an antenna and wonder why your system is not performing as expected. It is difficult for the end customer to determine if it is due to the antenna, or if the problem is with the connected equipment e.g. LTE/Wi-Fi router, M2M gateway, etc.”

To illustrate the extent of the problem, Fourie points to the case of one antenna which is being sold internationally as being an 88 dBi desktop antenna. He says this is a ludicrously high gain being claimed, and in reality it is a low gain antenna with very poor characteristics for its type. “The quoted 88 dBi is physically impossible even for an antenna hundreds of times larger in size. This is how far some suppliers will go to market their antennas, and they are quite successfully selling these antennas to unsuspecting consumers. A consumer could have purchased an antenna with much lower gain specifications from a reputable supplier and the customer experience would be much better,” he says.

As a further example, Fourie mentions another dubious antenna which was tested, which was designed and marketed for installation on a vehicle. “The antenna actually appeared to have reasonable test results – at first glance – but as soon as it was installed on a vehicle, the antenna’s performance went completely haywire. The VSWR was as high as 16:1, which is terrible.” He says the problem was that the antenna manufacturer never considered the effect of the ground plane on the antenna, which affects the performance of such an antenna when being mounted on a metallic surface – ironic considering the application it is intended for. Fourie says someone installing such an antenna might not notice it immediately, but will continuously have a problem with their communications reliability.

Poynting also looked at an antenna, suspiciously similar to one of its own antennas, only to discover it had several dry solder joints, the result of poor manufacturing quality and quality control. “Needless to say, this antenna was not even tested as it would have been a waste of time,” says Fourie.

Another example where an alleged copyright infringement was investigated, was where a company based in Asia produced an antenna which was an almost exact copy of a Poynting registered design for an older version of its antenna. Even though the antenna was almost a one to one copy, it performed poorly when compared. The company producing this antenna marketed the antenna at a much higher gain than the one it copied. “Customers are purchasing this type of antenna with poorer performance for almost the same price as the real thing, just to save a few bucks,” Fourie warns.

In closing, Fourie advises that consumers rather purchase from reputable companies. “The antenna might be a small portion of the cost of a communications system, but it can have devastating effects which can compromise the value of the entire system,” he concludes.


Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

AREI’s plans for 2020
29 January 2020 , Editor's Choice, News
Erich Nast, chairman of AREI, discusses what the association’s plans are to tackle the challenges and opportunities that lie ahead.

Check out Dataweek’s new-look website
29 January 2020, Technews Publishing , Editor's Choice, News
Our technical design elves have been locked away in our basement for months, improving the visual design and functionality of the Dataweek website.

V2X: The future of vehicle communications
29 January 2020, Avnet South Africa , Editor's Choice, Telecoms, Datacoms, Wireless, IoT
A recent report by Juniper Research forecasts that more than 62 million vehicles will be capable of vehicle-to-vehicle communication by 2023; up from just over 1,1 million in 2019.

High-performance IoT SoCs with dual processors
29 January 2020, RF Design , Telecoms, Datacoms, Wireless, IoT, Editor's Choice
Nordic Semiconductor’s new nRF5340 high-end multiprotocol system-on-chip (SoC) is the first member of its next generation of nRF5 Series SoCs. The nRF5340 builds on Nordic’s proven and globally adopted ...

Low-noise electronic circuitry enables low-intensity light detection
29 January 2020, Vepac Electronics , Editor's Choice, Power Electronics / Power Management
When it comes to low-intensity light detection, performance requirements often lead to selecting devices with greater sensitivity than common photodiodes or even charge coupled devices (CCDs).

What differentiates EMS companies
EMP 2020 Electronics Manufacturing & Production Handbook, Omnigo , Editor's Choice, Manufacturing / Production Technology, Hardware & Services
One of the major factors that differentiate electronics manufacturers from each other is the quality of the product that they deliver to the client and the time frame that they deliver the product within.

How to use spot mask for wave soldering and conformal coating
EMP 2020 Electronics Manufacturing & Production Handbook, Testerion , Editor's Choice, Manufacturing / Production Technology, Hardware & Services
Mask is applied over the open through-holes on a circuit board in the wave soldering process to make sure they stay open. This is necessary because without mask, any contact area on the bottom of the PCB will be fluxed and subsequently soldered.

Next-gen UV cure conformal coatings increase performance and speed up production
EMP 2020 Electronics Manufacturing & Production Handbook, Vepac Electronics , Editor's Choice, Manufacturing / Production Technology, Hardware & Services
Electronic circuits are becoming ubiquitous in modern life. Everywhere one looks, more and more processes that were once isolated and manual in nature, are being automated and now connected as the Internet ...

Implementation of environmentally sound cleaning
EMP 2020 Electronics Manufacturing & Production Handbook, Quamba Technologies , Editor's Choice, Manufacturing / Production Technology, Hardware & Services
The number of cleaning machines to be acquired was estimated based on the substrate surface that would need to be cleaned in the course of one year, adding a safety margin of 30%.

Process defect guide on QFN/LGA and bottom mounted components
EMP 2020 Electronics Manufacturing & Production Handbook , Editor's Choice, Manufacturing / Production Technology, Hardware & Services
A guide by Bob Willis of assembly defects that can occur with these components, which should help newcomers and expert users alike.