mobile | classic
Dataweek Electronics & Communications Technology Magazine

Follow us on:
Follow us on Facebook Share via Twitter Share via LinkedIn


Electronics Buyers' Guide

Electronics Manufacturing & Production Handbook 2017


Industry urged to submit waste management plans
21 February 2018, News

In December 2017, the government issued a gazette requiring the paper and packaging, electric and electronic, and lighting industries to prepare and submit Industry Waste Management Plans within nine months of the publication of the gazette. The three industries must submit their plans by 6 September 2018.

In addition, all producers in these industries must register with the department of energy within two months of the publication of the gazette.

All this is happening against a backdrop of the dismal history of failures in the plastic bag and tyre waste sector systems. The plastic bag initiative was government driven, while the tyre initiative was industry driven. One hopes that lessons have been learnt and future plans will mitigate against another unsuccessful implementation of a sector plan.

Levies and job creation

The latest call for industry waste management plans is a step in the right direction to achieve government’s goal of zero waste to landfill. The government must be lauded for enforcing responsibility for the full product lifecycle with manufactures and importers. This is a worldwide practice, and South Africa should be no exception. It is a huge opportunity to create job opportunities in the collection, transportation, storage and processing of waste.

Industry waste management plans reduce the opportunity for fence-sitting. They eliminate free riders and convoluted conspiracy theories, which are the Achilles heel of voluntary schemes. Hopefully, they will also kill off the unfortunate notion that industry should pay to have waste collected in voluntary schemes. Both public and private sector role-players regrettably subscribe to this view that is not supported by evidence, but continues to influence behaviour and practice.

On the other hand, the call for industry waste management plans could have a negative impact on those who will ultimately bear the brunt of regulated levies for waste collection and disposal. The negative comes only if it is not foreseen that the cost of recycling will be borne by the ultimate consumers of the products.

Whenever the government or industry imposes a levy on a product, the producers merely add the levy to the cost of production. To illustrate this point, consider the price of a litre of petrol. All the levies are tabulated separately and form part of the cost structure for the litre the consumer buys at a service station. The more the levies increase, the more expensive fuel becomes. Customers have to pay for whatever levy is agreed upon and implemented.

Waste collection EPR models

The government envisages two models or schemes for the management of producer responsibility organisations and the related collection of levies, namely, government versus industry managed schemes. In the industry managed scheme, an industry association effectively coordinates and facilitates all the recycling activities of that industry’s waste stream, and also collects their own levies directly from producers (indirectly from consumers). Naturally, but not always obviously, the customer is still the ultimate payer of the levy.

Alternatively, there would be a government managed scheme run directly by government or more likely by an organisation directly under government supervision. Under the government managed scheme, the government collects the levies, via Treasury.

There are three very significant downsides to a levy collected via central government. The first is that the government will impose an administrative fee of up to a quarter of the collected levies. So from the get-go, the recycling kitty reduces by 25% as a function of who collects the funds. Second, and most worrisome, there is no guarantee that the funds for recycling will be ring-fenced towards the purpose for which they were collected. Lastly, the consumer will ultimately pay more per kilogram for the recycling of waste. To achieve the same goals as the industry managed schemes, the customer must have the burden of an administered price from which there is no escape. No matter how much we could try, incorrect strategies implemented correctly could never achieve the best results.

If it is true that all solutions somehow have winners and losers, then it is fair to say that in the government managed scheme, the customer is the loser and the national fiscus is the winner. In the industry managed scheme, the opposite is true, if the scheme is efficiently managed.

It is not difficult to understand why industry managed or government managed schemes should work in collaboration with the Waste Bureau from the Department of Environmental Affairs. The government needs to have sight of what is happening within each waste stream, and that could be done easily and without much fanfare.

Producer responsibility and planning

The development and implementation of industry waste management plans have to be the responsibility of producer industry associations. Industry has to be responsible for the collection and disbursement of levies under tight governance controls. Generally, industry associations have a long history of robust corporate government without any one player allowed to exercise dominance.

The place for creativity, craftsmanship, and business skills should be exercised somewhere else down the value chain. The collection, transportation, storage, and processing of waste is a large enough space to allow for entrepreneurs to apply their skills and experience to earn a living and to create employment.

The anomaly in the tyre industry should be considered a misstep that should not be repeated. Placing producer responsibility organisations in self-interested companies or private hands, however disguised, is a recipe for disaster.

Similarly, independent non-profit organisations that are removed from the producers is an opportunity to manufacture malfeasance and news grabbing practices that are not related to reducing waste to the landfills and protecting the environment. The interface with the Waste Bureau is a good step so that the government is always in the loop regarding the activities of each waste stream. Otherwise the government will have a complete outsider view of what is happening and base its decisions on assumptions rather than what is the real situation.

We have to view these latest developments as an opportunity to create the right systems and architecture for the waste industry. We have an opportunity to do it right and minimise any unintended consequences of our actions. We have the hindsight of having implemented two incorrect approaches incorrectly, and not surprisingly, both haven’t been a resounding success. Now is a perfect opportunity to implement the correct processes correctly. We owe it to the future of our environment and future generations.

For more information contact the ROSE Foundation,

  Share on Facebook Share via Twitter Share via LinkedIn    

Further reading:

  • Electronics news digest
    21 February 2018, News
    Overseas    Business • Silicon Labs reported financial results for its fourth quarter ended 30 December 2017. Revenue in the fourth quarter ended at the high end of guidance at $201 million, up from $199 ...
  • TUT engineering lab gets state-of-the-art test equipment
    21 February 2018, Comtest, News
    The newly configured laboratory is used by a total of around 450 students, with 42 students accommodated per laboratory session for electrical measurement experiments and projects.
  • From the editor's desk: When will we get our first quantum computers?
    21 February 2018, Technews Publishing, News
    For the past few years, the buzz around quantum computing has been growing steadily louder, but it has mostly been coming from university laboratories and advanced corporate R&D facilities. Now household ...
  • Webb and Telegärtner connection strengthens
    21 February 2018, Webb Industries, News
    In spite of tough economic conditions globally, Germany’s international telecommunications and data solutions provider Telegärtner’s business with leading local telecommunications ancillary product specialist, ...
  • Electronics news digest
    31 January 2018, News
    South Africa • Reunert delivered strong results for fiscal 2017, with revenue of R9,77 billion representing a 15% year-on-year increase and profit increasing by 19% to R1,14 billion. Headline earnings ...
  • Don’t be fooled by substandard, cheap antennas
    31 January 2018, Poynting Antennas, This Week's Editor's Pick, News, Telecoms, Datacoms, Wireless
    Poynting has issued a public service announcement warning that it is seeing a large number of sub-standard antennas being sold to the public.
  • From the editor's desk: IoT protocols battle it out
    31 January 2018, Technews Publishing, News
    As the number of Internet of Things (IoT) applications grows, so too does the number of protocols supporting this proliferation. While each protocol has its own strengths and weaknesses, the resulting ...
  • Bird Technologies and Comtest launch new product in SA
    31 January 2018, Comtest, News
    Comtest Solutions recently hosted Bird Technologies’ sales manager, Mike Gathergood, at its Gauteng offices, as part of an extensive tour across the EMEA region he services, with a two-pronged objective. ...
  • SKA confirms synchronisation system designs
    31 January 2018, News
    One of the most critical and challenging design aspects of the Square Kilometre Array (SKA) radio telescope project, namely time synchronisation, came a step closer to resolution recently when the board ...
  • Monash offering engineering degrees
    31 January 2018, News
    Monash South Africa (MSA) has announced its academic offering for 2018 will be expanding, by offering engineering degrees within its expanded Faculty of Business, Engineering and Technology. The first ...
  • NWU speech research group joins engineering faculty
    31 January 2018, News
    The Multilingual Speech Technology research group (MuST) within the North-West University is joining forces with the NWU Faculty of Engineering in 2018. This research group focuses its efforts on the ...
  • Company profile: Connector Technology
    31 January 2018, Connector Technology, News
    Stretching back to 1992, Connector Technology has been providing customised connector, cabling and harnessing solutions for the South African electronics manufacturing industry. Today the company has ...

Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd
1st Floor, Stabilitas House
265 Kent Ave, Randburg, 2194
South Africa
Publications by Technews
Dataweek Electronics & Communications Technology
Electronic Buyers Guide (EBG)

Hi-Tech Security Solutions
Hi-Tech Security Business Directory

Motion Control in Southern Africa
Motion Control Buyers’ Guide (MCBG)

South African Instrumentation & Control
South African Instrumentation & Control Buyers’ Guide (IBG)
Terms & conditions of use, including privacy policy
PAIA Manual


    Classic | Mobile

Copyright © Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd. All rights reserved.